Roofing cost and lifespan
Should I repair or replace my roof?
By Nate Hadachek, CEO, Impact Energy & RoofingPart of Roofing
Repair when the damage is small and local and the roof has good years left. Replace when the roof is near the end of its life, damage is spread across several slopes, leaks keep coming back, or the decking underneath is failing. Solar on top can tip a borderline roof toward replacement, because every later re-roof means taking the panels off.
Five questions decide most of these calls: how old the roof is, how far the damage has spread, whether leaks keep coming back, what shape the decking is in, and whether solar sits on top. If the answers land on both sides, that's normal. Get a written price both ways and compare.
How old is the roof?
Age is the first filter. InterNACHI's chart estimates about 20 years for 3-tab asphalt shingles and about 30 for architectural shingles under normal wear 1. Colorado's sun, hail and freeze-thaw usually pull those down.
- Young roof: repair is usually the answer unless a storm did widespread damage.
- Middle-aged roof: it depends on the rest of this list.
- Near or past its expected life: a repair buys time, not years. Put the money toward a replacement plan.
How far has the damage spread?
One torn shingle, a lifted ridge cap or a cracked pipe boot is a repair. Wind damage on one slope is often a repair too.
When damage shows up on most slopes, as it does after a real hailstorm, spot repairs stop making sense. You'd be patching around shingles that took the same hits as the ones you're replacing. If repairs would touch a large share of the roof, get both prices. Not sure if hail got yours? Read how to tell if hail damaged your roof.
Do the leaks keep coming back?
A leak that's fixed once and stays fixed was a repair. A roof that leaks in a new spot every spring is telling you the whole system is worn out. Every leak also puts water into the attic, insulation and ceiling, and that damage costs more than shingles.
Is the decking sound?
The deck is the plywood or OSB under the shingles. Signs it's failing:
- Soft or spongy spots a roofer finds walking the roof
- A sagging roofline
- Daylight, dark stains or damp wood seen from the attic
Rotted decking can't be fixed from the top by adding new shingles. If a lot of it is bad, a full tear-off lets the bad sheets be replaced and the roof start clean.
What if there's solar on top?
Panels change the math. A repair near or under the array may mean moving panels to reach it. A full replacement means taking the whole array off and putting it back.
- Roof under existing panels is borderline: a repair now and a replacement in a few years means two rounds of panel work. Price both paths.
- Planning to add solar: if the roof is in the back half of its life, replacing it first usually makes more sense than putting panels on it now.
How that job runs is in replacing a roof that has solar on it.
What about insurance?
If a covered storm caused the damage, your insurer's adjuster decides what the policy pays for, whether that's a repair or a replacement. We inspect, document the damage with dated photos, and can meet your adjuster on the roof. The claim and the deductible are yours. Your insurer decides coverage. See hail damage and homeowners insurance.
What does a replacement look like when it's the right call?
On a Front Range re-roof, the old roof came off to the deck, the crew laid the new roof, and the debris went out by dump truck. See the photos from the Front Range re-roof. Cost drivers for a job like that are in what a new roof costs in Colorado.
How do the signs add up?
| Question | Leans repair | Leans replace |
|---|---|---|
| Age | Lots of life left | Near or past expected life |
| Damage | One spot or one slope | Most slopes |
| Leaks | One, fixed and stayed fixed | Recurring, new spots |
| Decking | Solid | Soft, sagging, stained |
| Solar | None planned | Panels on it or going on soon |
Save this
- Check the roof's age against its material.
- Count the slopes with damage, not just the shingles.
- Note every leak and when it happened.
- Get a written repair price and a written replacement price. repair price and a written replacement price.
- Ask whether deck repair is included and how it's priced.
- If you have solar, ask how panel removal is handled either way.
For the work itself, see roof repair, roof replacement and the roofing page. Not sure which side your roof is on? Call (888) 240-1131 or request an inspection.
Questions
Can I replace just one slope of my roof?
Sometimes, if the rest of the roof is sound. New shingles rarely match weathered ones exactly, and a patched roof ages unevenly, so ask whether a partial replacement makes sense on your house.
Will new shingles match my old ones on a repair?
Often not exactly. Shingle lines change and older shingles fade in the sun. A small repair on a back slope may not matter. A patch on the street side can stand out.
How many repairs is too many?
When you're fixing a new spot every season, or the repairs add up to a large share of the roof, get a replacement price next to the repair price and compare.
Should I repair or replace before selling my house?
It depends on the roof and your market. Buyers and inspectors look hard at an older roof. Get an inspection and a written price both ways before you list.
Sources
- [1]InterNACHI's Standard Estimated Life Expectancy Chart for Homes. International Association of Certified Home Inspectors (InterNACHI)
Keep exploring
Services this helps with
- Roof replacementWe tear off worn-out and storm-damaged roofs down to the deck and build a new roof system on homes across the Denver metro and Front Range. You choose the material and get a written price before work starts.
- Roof repairWe repair leaks, missing shingles, failed flashing and storm damage in one area of a roof, on homes and small businesses across the Denver metro and Front Range. We find where the water gets in, show you photos, and fix the cause.
- Emergency roofingWater coming through the ceiling or a roof torn open by wind? Call (888) 240-1131 and we'll tell you when we can get there. We tarp or seal the roof to stop more water, document the damage, then plan the permanent fix.
Tell us about the roof, the panels or the building.
Send the form or call. We set up an assessment, then send a written proposal with the scope and the price.
Monday–Friday 9 a.m.–5 p.m.
General information about roofing and solar in Colorado, not legal, tax or insurance advice.
Answers on this site are general information about roofing and solar in Colorado, not legal, tax or insurance advice. Programs, codes and utility rules change; your written proposal and your insurer or utility have the final word.